Hiring Employees vs Subcontractors: How Contractors Should Decide
A deep dive on Working Overtime episode 1: what employees and subs really cost, how the government tells them apart, what you give up in control, and a 90-day test to decide which one you need.
Updated Nov 18, 2026
The short answer
Hire employees for steady, core work you need to control, and use subcontractors for overflow, seasonal peaks, and specialty jobs. Employees cost 25% to 40% more than their wage once taxes, insurance, and benefits are added, and you pay them on slow days. Subs cost more per hour but stop costing when the work stops. Whatever you call a worker, the government decides their status based on how you treat them.
You've got more work than your crew can handle. You're turning down jobs, the same guys are working overtime every week, and it feels like something's about to break. You have two options: hire employees or bring in subcontractors.
Most contractors go with whoever picks up the phone first. That's how you end up with a crew you can't control, or a payroll you can't afford.
In episode 1 of Working Overtime, our video series for trade business owners, we break the decision into three parts: the real cost, control, and how steady your work is. Watch the episode below, then read on for the details, the math, and a checklist you can use this week.
The short version
| Employees | Subcontractors | |
|---|---|---|
| Hourly cost | Lower rate, plus 25–40% on top of wages | Higher rate that already covers their taxes, insurance, and overhead |
| Slow weeks | You still pay them, or cut hours | Cost stops when the work stops |
| Control | You set the schedule, methods, and standards | You set the result and the deadline, not how or when |
| Availability | On your calendar | May be on someone else's job when you need them |
| Admin | Withholding, payroll taxes, overtime rules | Pay the invoice and file year-end tax forms |
| Long term | Learn your way of working and grow into leads | Capacity when you need it |
| Best for | Steady, core work every week | Overflow, peaks, and specialty work |
Subs rent you capacity. Employees build your company.
Neither one is better. They solve different problems. The trick is matching each one to the right kind of work, and making sure you're treating each the way the law expects.
1. The real cost: both numbers are lying to you
A sub's rate usually looks high, and an employee's wage looks low. Neither number tells you what you'll actually pay.
What an employee really costs
The wage is just the start. On top of it you pay:
- Your share of payroll taxes. In the U.S., employers pay 6.2% for Social Security and 1.45% for Medicare on wages.
- Unemployment insurance, federal and state.
- Workers' compensation, which can be expensive in high-risk trades.
- Benefits and paid time off, if you offer them.
- Tools, gear, and training.
A common rule of thumb is that an employee costs 25% to 40% more than their base wage. So a worker you pay $30 an hour might really cost you $37 to $42 an hour.
Then there's the part most owners forget: you pay employees on slow days too. If you pay for 40 hours but only have 32 hours of billable work, every billable hour has to carry the cost of the other eight.
| Example | Amount |
|---|---|
| Base wage | $30.00/hr |
| Fully loaded cost (35% on top) | $40.50/hr |
| Paid hours in a week | 40 |
| Weekly cost | $1,620 |
| Billable hours that week | 32 |
| Real cost per billable hour | $50.63/hr |
This is an example. Your burden depends on your state or province, your workers' comp rate, and your benefits. Our guide on how to calculate labor costs for a construction job and the free bill rate calculator will help you work out your own.
What a sub really costs
A sub's rate is higher because it already includes their own taxes, insurance, tools, and overhead. You don't withhold taxes or pay benefits. You pay their invoice and file the required year-end tax forms.
And you only pay for the work you need. In the example above, a sub charging $50 an hour costs about the same as an employee who's only busy 32 hours a week. If your employee is busy all 40, they're the cheaper option. If they're only busy 25, the sub is.
That's the real question: not "which rate is lower," but "how much of the time will I actually use what I'm paying for?"
The two risks of using subs
Subs look simpler on paper. But there are two risks that catch a lot of contractors out.
Risk 1: Worker misclassification
This is the big one in construction. You don't get to decide whether someone is a sub or an employee by what you call them, or by the paperwork you both signed. The government decides based on how you actually treat them.
If you call someone a sub but treat them like an employee, you can be on the hook for back payroll taxes, interest, unpaid overtime, workers' comp claims, and sometimes penalties.
In the U.S., the IRS looks at three areas:
- Behavioral control: Do you tell them how, when, and where to do the work?
- Financial control: Do they use their own tools, set their own rates, work for other customers, and risk losing money on a job?
- The relationship: Is the work ongoing, and is it a core part of your business? Do you give them benefits?
The Department of Labor and many states apply their own tests too, and some are stricter. In Canada, outside Quebec, the CRA looks at similar factors, including the level of control, who provides the tools and equipment, and whether the worker can make a profit or take a loss. Quebec uses its own civil-law factors.
A simple gut check: if someone works only for you, on your schedule, with your tools, doing your core work, they're almost certainly an employee.
Rules vary by country, state, and province. If you're unsure about a specific worker, talk to an accountant or employment lawyer before you set up the arrangement, not after an audit.
Risk 2: Insurance
If a sub doesn't carry their own general liability and workers' comp and they get hurt on your job, your policy, or your GC's, can end up paying. And when your insurer audits you, they may charge you premium for every uninsured sub you used.
Before any sub sets foot on your job site, get three things:
2. Flexibility vs control
What subs give you
- Flexibility. Bring them in for a big job or a busy season. When the work runs out, so does the cost.
- Skills on demand. Specialty work you don't do often enough to hire for.
- Their own tools and equipment, which can keep your equipment costs down.
What you give up
Control. With a sub, you set the result and the deadline, and that's it. You can't tell them how to do the work or when to show up. If you start controlling those things, legally they should probably be an employee.
Subs also work for other people, so when you need them most, they might be on someone else's job. And if they do sloppy work, your GC or customer won't blame the sub. They'll blame you.
What employees give you
Full control. You set the schedule, the methods, the quality standards, and even the PPE they wear on site. They're on your calendar, so you can move them on short notice.
Over time, they learn your way of doing things. The best ones grow into leads and foremen. That's how you build a company that doesn't need you on every site, every day. See how to turn a great tradesperson into a great crew leader.
3. Steady work vs lumpy work
The easiest way to think about it: steady work suits employees, and lumpy work suits subs.
If you're busy all year, employees make sense. You're actually using the capacity you're paying for. If you have big seasonal peaks, hiring for the peak means paying people to stand around in slow months, or laying them off. Neither is good for your business or your reputation.
Watch your overtime
Overtime is the warning sign most owners ignore. If your crew is working overtime week after week, that's not a busy season. You're short-staffed.
Constant overtime usually costs more than a new hire. In the U.S., overtime for non-exempt workers is at least time and a half after 40 hours in a workweek, and some states add daily overtime rules. On top of the cost, it burns out your best people, the ones you can least afford to lose. See why good crew members leave.
A quick check: add up the overtime hours your crew worked over the last eight weeks. If it's close to a full-time person's hours, you're already paying for a hire, just at time and a half.
What works best for most small contractors
- Employees for your core crew, the people doing your main work every single week.
- Subs for overflow, seasonal peaks, and short, clearly defined jobs.
- Subs for specialty work you don't do often enough to justify a hire.
Do this week: the 90-day test
This is the exercise from the end of the episode. It takes about an hour, and it turns a gut feeling into a clear answer.
Whichever way you go, know where your hours go
Hiring or subbing out only works if you know what your labor really costs. That means knowing where your people are, which job each hour belongs to, and how much overtime is building up before payroll.
Supercrew tracks your crew's hours with Automatic Clock In, ties each hour to the right job, shows labor against your job budgets, and applies your overtime rules as hours come in. When you're deciding whether to hire, you'll have real numbers instead of a gut feeling. Try Supercrew free for 7 days.
Want more like this? Watch Working Overtime for more lessons on running and growing a trades business.
Frequently asked questions
Is it cheaper to hire an employee or a subcontractor?
It depends on how busy they'll be. An employee's real cost is often 25% to 40% above their wage, and you pay them on slow days. A sub charges more per hour but only for the work you need. If you have steady work for a full week, an employee is usually cheaper. If the work is lumpy, a sub often is.
How much more than their wage does an employee cost?
A common rule of thumb is 25% to 40% more, for payroll taxes, unemployment insurance, workers' comp, benefits, paid time off, tools, and training. A $30 an hour worker might really cost $37 to $42 an hour.
How does the IRS decide if a worker is a contractor or an employee?
It looks at behavioral control (do you control how, when, and where they work?), financial control (do they use their own tools, set rates, work for others, and risk a loss?), and the relationship (is the work ongoing and core to your business?). Labels and contracts alone don't decide it.
What happens if I misclassify an employee as a subcontractor?
You can owe back payroll taxes, interest, unpaid overtime, and workers' comp costs, and sometimes penalties. Rules vary by country, state, and province, so check with an accountant or employment lawyer if you're unsure.
What should I get from a subcontractor before they start?
A current certificate of insurance showing general liability and workers' comp, their tax identification number (a Form W-9 in the U.S.), and a written contract covering scope, price, schedule, and payment terms.
When should a contractor hire instead of using subs?
When you have steady core work every week, need control over how and when it's done, or your crew has worked overtime week after week. Constant overtime usually means you're short-staffed.
Sources
- IRS, Independent contractor (self-employed) or employee?
- U.S. Department of Labor, Misclassification of employees as independent contractors
- Canada Revenue Agency, Employment status: contract formed outside of Quebec
- IRS, Topic 751: Social Security and Medicare withholding rates
- U.S. Department of Labor, Fact Sheet #23: Overtime Pay